Ref Review: Southampton triumph despite Lee Mason’s shocker at the Britannia

Alex Vryzakis struggles to comprehend just how poor a show of officiating it was when Southampton took on Stoke at the Britannia on Saturday.


Stoke 1-2 Southampton

Ref: Lee Mason

The only positive element that Lee Mason can take away from this clash is that his errors did not adversely affect the result, or indeed Southampton’s win. It was as if the referee was simply unable to make any sort of call resembling the correct one, baffling both players and fans alike at the Britannia.

The first major incident came when Dusan Tadic clashed quite heavily with Jack Butland in the box. As the Saints player came racing into the area, the goalkeeper made the rash decision to rush out for it, knocking the player in the process. Even without replays it was obvious that there had been contact (although Tadic’s dramatics could have been done without).

It was an obvious penalty decision.

It was therefore baffling to see Mason point for a goal-kick. Surely this meant that he deemed there to have been no contact between the two players, and therefore that Tadic had dived. But if that were the case, then he needed to send Tadic off with a second yellow. His indecision, neither giving a penalty nor a booking, showed a surprising lack of backbone, infuriating both teams.

But Mason made an even more mystifying decision late on in the match. As Southampton’s Sadio Mané and Stoke’s Erik Pieters both went for a high ball, there was a clash of heads – a fairly routine scene on a football field. Pieters came off worse and lay on the ground, but – for a reason unknown – Mason showed the astonished Mané a red card.

Both players had kept their eyes on the ball during the clash, and neither raised an elbow. To send off Mané for seemingly violent conduct was a crazy decision, and even the usual one-eyed Mark Hughes seemed baffled in his post-match interview.

This was a day that Mason will hope to quickly forget, as it seemed his lack of refereeing nouse was thoroughly and shockingly exposed.

Grade: D. A calamitous showing from Mason.

Read more from Alex here
Follow Alex at @AlexVryzakis

Advertisements
About lakirk41 (93 Articles)
24, Cambridge grad, Arsenal fan, unfortunate hair colour

1 Comment on Ref Review: Southampton triumph despite Lee Mason’s shocker at the Britannia

  1. Ian Probert // March 15, 2016 at 6:09 pm // Reply

    To be honest, those decisions were the least of it.
    He allowed a number of obvious fouls to go unpunished, which frustrated fans, then started pulling cards out of his pocked in the second half, by which time he had lost control of the game.
    It didn’t affect the result, as a Stokie I accept thatSouthampton won and deservedly so, but it was a refereeing display so poor it beggared belief

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: